Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Clinical Microbiology, January 2007, p. 26-30, Vol. 45, No. 1
0095-1137/07/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JCM.02230-06
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
| MINIREVIEW |

Division of Infectious Diseases, Laboratory Sciences of Arizona/Sonora Quest Laboratories, Tempe,1 Department of Internal Medicine, Banner Good Samaritan Medical Center, Phoenix,2 Department of Medicine, University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson, Arizona3
|
|
|---|
Until the 1990s, the genus Coccidioides was thought to have only one species. No teleomorph (sexual form) has been described. Molecular phylogenetic methods have since shown that there are definite differences between isolates originating from diverse geographic locations, such as California (CA), Arizona (AZ), Texas (TX), Mexico, and South America (SA). The strains fall into two phylogenetic clades representing separate evolutionary species. One group (Group II) contains isolates originating from CA, while a second group (Group I) contains isolates from outside of CA (non-CA), inclusive of those from AZ, TX, Mexico, and SA. These clades have now been given species rank (4). The CA group (Group II) retained the species name of C. immitis, while the non-CA group (Group I) was named C. posadasii Fisher, Koenig, White, et Taylor, sp. nov. (2, 4).
The incidence of coccidioidomycosis is increasing. Progressively greater numbers of cases are being reported to the Arizona Department of Health Services (ADHS); 2,695 cases were reported in 2003, and 3,515 were reported in 2005. Preliminary data indicate that 3,036 cases were reported to the ADHS in the first 6 months of 2006 (ADHS, personal communication).
Clinical infection can occur in any age group, most commonly 30- to 75-year-olds in AZ. Increased risk of infection is associated with outdoor activity. Incidence may be dependent on interspersed seasonal precipitation, severity of wind and dust storms, continued regional influx of susceptible hosts, and disruption and aerosolization of the desert surface by construction, wildfires, and earthquakes (6, 11). Commonly, two peak periods of activity (spring and end of summer) occur in AZ, and one (end of summer) occurs in CA. Factors governing the recent increases in coccidioidomycosis are environmental rather than genetic. Business and tourist travel to areas of endemicity is increasing the chance of patients being diagnosed with coccidioidomycosis outside such areas. With as many as 150,000 new cases being estimated to occur each year, travel history should always be sought in the evaluation of patients (3, 5).
Symptoms usually begin within 7 to 21 days of inhalation of arthroconidia. Symptomatic patients complain of fever, cough, chest discomfort, malaise, and fatigue. Twenty percent of primary coccidioidal pneumonia is associated with headache. Symptoms generally last less than 3 weeks, although protracted fatigue may become prominent. Transient skin manifestations, including rash and erythema nodosum, may be seen in 10% to 50% of patients. About 25% of cases of pulmonary disease appear similar to many community-acquired pneumonias, with pleuritic pain, cough (usually nonproductive), fever, arthralgias, and myalgias. Empirical therapy for presumed bacterial pneumonia is often given, and the natural course of symptom resolution deceives the clinician. Progressive pneumonia may involve the pleura and necrosis with cavitation. Problems occur if steroids are used or underlying host-compromising conditions exist. The majority of patients with extensive pulmonary involvement do not have extrapulmonary disease. The evaluation of the solitary pulmonary nodule is more complex when a past history of coccidioidomycosis is elicited. Such pulmonary nodules may mimic neoplasia and are usually serologically negative (1).
Disseminated coccidioidomycosis is estimated to occur in less than 5% of symptomatic patients and probably less than 1% of all infections. Patients of black or Asian (especially Filipino) ethnic backgrounds, pregnant women in the third trimester, and any immunocompromised patients appear to be at significant risk for disseminated disease. Dissemination may occur months to several years after the primary infection. The general role of the immune system in handling coccidioidal antigen is recognized, but it is unclear why some patients have few or no symptoms and others have disseminated disease. Host genes and in particular HLA class II and ABO blood group may play a role in dissemination and severity of infection.
Dissemination of spherules and endospores via the lymphatics and the bloodstream may occur to any organ system, but skin, lymph nodes, and the skeletal system are primarily involved. Meningeal disease is less common. The gastrointestinal tract is rarely involved. Infection after traumatic percutaneous inoculation with arthroconidia occurs rarely, mimicking cutaneous nocardiosis or sporotrichosis.
Direct detection. (i) Microscopy. In immunocompetent patients, inflammatory changes normally occur in two phases, early and late. The early phase includes a mixed acute reaction consisting of an influx of polymorphonuclear neutrophils and, to a far lesser degree, granulomatous cells (13). Tissue eosinophilia may be present and may be seen surrounding the offending organism (Splendore-Höeppli phenomenon). As endospores mature into spherules, a granulomatous reaction predominates, with an influx of lymphocytes, plasma cells, and multinucleated giant cells. Mixed inflammatory reactions may occur as spherules release endospores, thereby precipitating the reoccurrence of a polymorphonuclear neutrophil response.
Coccidioidomycosis can be diagnosed microscopically by visualization of endospore-containing spherules in infected material. Potassium hydroxide (KOH) wet mounts are useful and readily available for microscopic evaluations but lack the sensitivity and specificity of several other staining methods. The calcofluor white (CFW) fluorescent stain affords the best ability to detect fungi by binding the chitin and cellulose found in their cell walls (13). In an observation of 374 culture-positive specimens in the Phoenix area, the overall sensitivity of the CFW stain was 22% (D. Sussland and M. A. Saubolle, unpublished data). CFW stains plant and fatty material nonspecifically. Reading the stain, therefore, requires well-trained personnel and strict attention to morphological detail.
The Grocott-methenamine silver stain is most sensitive in detecting fungi in histopathological preparations. However, it may overstain fungal material (potentially masking internal structures such as endospores within spherules) and tissue elements (e.g., mucus droplets and glycogen granules), as well as some bacteria. Other commonly used histological stains, such as the periodic acid-Schiff stain and the hematoxylin-eosin stain, are not considered to be as sensitive as the Grocott-methenamine silver stain. Occasionally, the Giemsa, Papanicolau, and mucicarmine stains may differentiate Coccidioides organisms in specimen preparations (13). The Gram stain does not normally stain Coccidioides spp. and should not be used as a primary screening method.
The presence of endospore-containing spherules is diagnostic of coccidioidomycosis. However, mycelial forms may also be observed in specimens collected from peripheries of cavitary or skin lesions; without the presence of spherules, these do not provide the identity of the fungus. At times, endospores may predominate as the morphological form in specimens and may be mistaken for yeast forms of Histoplasma, Cryptococcus, or Candida (Fig. 1). Small, immature spherules abutting each other may be confused with budding yeast forms of Blastomyces (11, 13).
![]() View larger version (80K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Endospores seen in a Wright's stain of cerebrospinal fluid of a patient with coccidioidal meningitis. Magnification, x1,000.
|
Culture. (i) Safety. Arthroconidia pose high risk in the clinical laboratory. Safety features for the mycology laboratory should at the minimum include negative air pressure in the work area, biosafety level 2 practices, presence of a class II biological safety cabinet, and procedures and practices delineating standard precautions. Some suggest that biosafety level 3 practices be maintained in the mycology laboratory. Care must be observed in the routine laboratory as well, since unsuspected Coccidioides sp. isolates grow well on routine bacterial media.
(ii) Select agent status. Both species of Coccidioides are considered by the federal government to be select agents of bioterrorism, and laboratories isolating such isolates must follow strict mandates (7). Laboratories registered with the government to handle select agents must follow rules for defined work practices, documentation and inventory controls of isolates, background checks of all involved employees, strictly restricted access to work areas, and monthly reporting to the CDC and must pay registration fees. Laboratories that are not registered must appropriately destroy all isolates and advise the CDC of each isolate and its disposition in writing within 7 days of identification. Identified isolates cannot be transferred for any reason without prior written permission from the CDC.
(iii) Isolation. Coccidioides spp. can be grown on most fungal media (Sabouraud medium, inhibitory mold agar, and medium containing cycloheximide) and bacterial media (sheep blood and chocolate agar media as well as selective yeast extract medium used for Legionella) (11). Specimens containing mixed flora should always be plated onto selective medium as well, since Coccidioides spp. do not compete well with other bacteria or molds. Growth is usually recognizable within 4 to 5 days on most media. Study of 1,513 cultures positive for Coccidioides spp. over a 6-year period in the Phoenix area found the average days to detection to be 4.4 days (range, 2 to 16 days) (D. Sussland and M. A. Saubolle, unpublished data). The average days to detection for smear-positive specimens was 2.6 days shorter than for those with negative smears (3.9 days versus 6.5 days, respectively). Yet the most common day of detection in both groups was the fourth day. Young colonies (2 to 3 days after visually detectable growth) do not have arthroconidia. Colonies are usually white to buff but may assume a variety of colors, especially upon aging. Production of characteristic arthroconidia occurs as the colony grows and may be used to presumptively identify the mold. If spherules with endospores are noted on direct microscopy, further confirmation of the identity is unnecessary.
Confirmation of an isolate as Coccidioides spp. is best achieved using a molecular genus-specific genetic probe (GenProbe, San Diego, CA). The probe recognizes both species but does not differentiate between them. Nonviable controls may be maintained by inactivating previously confirmed isolates. Autoclaving and formalin should not be used to kill an isolate, as these might cause false negative reactions to occur with the probes. With the introduction of the molecular probe method of identification, older methods, such as immunodiffusion of exoantigen for lines of identity, propagation of the spherule phase in Converse medium, or mouse inoculation studies, are no longer commonly used (11).
It is difficult to phenotypically differentiate between C. immitis and C. posadasii. It has been noted that C. posadasii grows significantly faster at 37°C in vitro than does C. immitis (B. Barker, S. Statt, J. Galgiani, and M. Orbach, Abstr. 6th Int. Symp. Coccidioidomycosis, abstr. 9, 2006). However, it is clinically unnecessary to routinely differentiate between the two species at present, as the two seem to have almost identical clinical presentations and antifungal susceptibility profiles. This may change as more is learned about the two species.
Predictably, the respiratory tract provides the highest recovery rate in culture of Coccidioides spp. The experience in a mycology section located in Phoenix (Table 1) (D. Sussland and M. A. Saubolle, unpublished data) showed an overall recovery rate of 3.2% from all specimens submitted for fungal culture (n = 55,788) over a 6-year period and a respiratory tract rate of 8.3% (n = 10,372). Recovery rates dropped to 0.4% for blood cultures (n = 5,026) and 0.6% for urine cultures (n = 649). The central nervous system (CNS) also had a poor recovery rate (0.9%). The standard method for diagnosis of CNS coccidioidomycosis is serological rather than by culture.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Recovery of Coccidioides spp. by source at Laboratory Sciences of Arizona in the Phoenix metropolitan area, 1998 to 2003a
|
Serologies. Cell-mediated immunity is protective in the host. Skin testing with fungus-specific antigen preparations (spherulin or coccidioidin) was a mainstay in surveillance studies of coccidioidomycosis activity. Unfortunately, the preparations are no longer available in the United States.
Humoral antibodies are not protective against Coccidioides spp. but reflect the organism's level of activity in the infected host and are used for the diagnosis and prognosis of the disease. The timing and magnitude of the antibody response are directly related to the integrity of the patient's immune system and to the specific clinical presentation of infection. The serologic response can simplistically be broken down into the production of early (immunoglobulin M [IgM]) and late (IgG) antibodies (9, 10, 14). Early IgM (often referred to as tube precipitin or TP) antibody becomes measurable within 1 (50% of cases) to 3 (90% of cases) weeks of onset. IgG (often referred to as complement fixation or CF) antibody becomes measurable sometime between the second and third weeks of onset or later (up to several months). IgG antibody may remain for months, and its titer is usually related to the degree of infection. Serologic studies may be compromised in patients with decreased immune response (e.g., transplant patients or those with human immunodeficiency virus infection).
Enzyme immunoassays (EIA) are now available for detection of both IgM and IgG and are seemingly the most sensitive. A negative result by EIA does not have to be confirmed by any of the other methods. Immunodiffusion (IMDF) methods are available for detection of IgM and IgG as well, but they require longer incubation periods (up to 4 days) to rule out negatives. The IMDF tests are normally qualitative but can be altered to quantitate titers. This may be useful in testing sera which show anticomplementary activity in CF studies. Quantitative CF studies for IgG are used primarily for monitoring the activity and prognosis of coccidioidomycosis. Increasing CF titers or those above 1:32 suggest heightened activity and possible dissemination. Because of its lessened sensitivity, the CF test should not be used as the sole diagnostic tool for coccidioidomycosis. The CF test is useful for the diagnosis of meningeal disease. Pleural and synovial fluids may be tested by the CF test, but their diagnostic efficacy is controversial. Different CF values may be obtained by laboratories using differing test methods and reagents; thus, results must be interpreted cautiously and only in the context of the whole clinical picture. In measuring infection activity, it is best to concurrently test antibody levels in sera collected sequentially over a time period (i.e., the most recent against a previous). There may also be significant discrepancies between EIA, IMDF, and CF study results; this is especially true between results of EIA and IMDF IgM studies.
In one retrospective analysis of EIA, IMDF, and CF tests on culture-positive patients during the acute disease phase, data showed an overall test sensitivity of only 82%. Thus, negative serologies do not rule out coccidioidomycosis, especially early in the disease phase. Individually, the studies showed sensitivities of 83% for EIA, 71% for IMDF, and 56% for CF (C. R. Pollage, E. Billetdeaux, A. Phansalkar, M. Litwin, and C. A. Petti, Abstr. Ann. Meet. Am. Soc. Microbiol., abstr. F-005, 2006). Although EIA IgM and IgG were the most sensitive methods, they may show less specificity than the other methods, especially if the IgM-specific test alone is reactive.
Wheat et al. recently reported that the histoplasma urine antigen test was reactive in approximately 50% of patients with systemic coccidioidomycosis (L. Wheat, T. Kuberski, A. Myers, M. Durkin, and P. Connolly, Abstr. 6th Int. Symp. Coccidioidomycosis, abstr. 20, 2006). This seems to be due to cross-reaction between the two antigens in the urine test. A more sensitive and specific urinary antigen test for Coccidioides spp. is presently being sought.
Coccidioidomycosis is not a benign disease that afflicts only a few unfortunate or immunosuppressed hosts. Population growth in the southwestern United States will escalate the impact of this disease. Better therapies may include immunotherapy in the future. Much work is ongoing in the formulation of vaccines. However, a clinically efficacious vaccine is likely to be a long time in coming.
Published ahead of print on 15 November 2006. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»